コンテンツにスキップ

英文维基 | 中文维基 | 日文维基 | 草榴社区

ノート:夏姫

ページのコンテンツが他言語でサポートされていません。

Historically Inaccurate & Sensationalist

[編集]

Sorry I can't write in Japanese. But from what I can understand here, this entry seems to be largely based upon an erotic novel instead of historical facts. Historically there was never any recording that 夏姫 was raped/forced into sexual relationships with anybody. She seemed to have voluntarily entered into every sexual relationship that she had, with her own consent. In fact, as a noblewoman, it was simply impossible that other noblemen/soldiers could rape her at will, and she would have to consent to the intercourses before they happen. So I think the way this entry is currently presented seems to be really inaccurate, sensationalist and disrespectful to the actual historical person 夏姫. This is Wikipedia for God's sake, not a place for erotic works! Hopefully somebody who can write in Japanese would be able to correct this item, referring to historical records/Chinese Wikipedia.

Also it seems that the original author of this entry has already been banned, so it seems even more possible that he was not treating Wikipedia with seriousness.

--SZJX会話2016年2月8日 (月) 16:43 (UTC)[返信]